From Side Hustle to $260M: The Wild Wins & Fails of Andrew Wilkinson

Plus best and worst business ideas ranked inside

Author

Joshua Clear
June 04, 2025

In partnership with

LLC, S Corp, or Sole Proprietor? Download Besolo’s Free Guide

Each business structure has unique benefits, risks, and financial implications. Our definitive Solopreneur’s Guide breaks down LLCs, S Corps, and Sole Proprietorships in easy-to-follow terms, ensuring you’re fully informed to make strategic choices for your solo business.

👥 Who's On the Mic? Meet the Players

This episode of My First Million (MFM) features Andrew Wilkinson, the entrepreneurial force behind Tiny (formerly Tiny Capital)—often dubbed the “Berkshire Hathaway of internet companies.” Wilkinson’s knack? Buying, building, and scaling digital businesses with a no-nonsense, Buffett-inspired approach. Alongside hosts Sam Parr and Shaan Puri, Andrew unpacks his best and worst business ideas, revealing the real stories behind the headlines and valuations1.

🎙️ EPISODE SNAPSHOT

Ever wondered what separates a cash cow from a cash drain in the startup world? In this episode, Andrew Wilkinson pulls back the curtain on his wildest wins and cringiest flops, serving up a masterclass in business model selection, risk, and regret. If you want to shortcut years of entrepreneurial trial and error, this is the episode you can’t afford to miss1.

💡 KEY TAKEAWAYS

  • Automatic Revenue Is King: Andrew’s biggest wins came from businesses that generated recurring, “while-you-sleep” revenue—think digital products and SaaS, not brick-and-mortar headaches1.

  • Agencies Are a Medium Difficulty Game: Running an agency is no walk in the park, but it’s a lot easier than managing physical goods or large teams. Service businesses are a solid entry point but rarely scale as easily as digital products1.

  • The Power of Postmortems: Wilkinson’s willingness to dissect both his successes and failures is a cheat code for learning. He emphasizes that pain is the best teacher—each flop taught him what to avoid next time1.

  • Don’t Sell Too Early: One of Andrew’s biggest regrets? Selling a fast-growing, high-margin business before he truly understood its value. Sometimes, the grass isn’t greener on the other side—it’s just more work1.

  • Read Like Your Net Worth Depends On It: A voracious appetite for business books and Buffett letters transformed Andrew from rookie to rainmaker in under a decade1.

🛠️ TOOLS, WEBSITES, RESOURCES MENTIONED

  • Tumblr & Shopify: Platforms where Andrew launched and scaled Pixel Union, his digital theme business1.

  • Tiny (tiny.com): Andrew’s holding company, modeled after Berkshire Hathaway, that acquires and operates internet businesses1.

  • Warren Buffett’s Letters: A recurring reference point for business philosophy, capital allocation, and operational excellence1.

  • WeCommerce: The public company that Pixel Union eventually became, after acquisitions and a public offering1.

💼 BUSINESS IDEAS & OPPORTUNITIES

  • Digital Product Marketplaces: Selling website themes or templates for platforms like Shopify and Tumblr—low overhead, global reach, and recurring sales while you sleep1.

  • Agency Incubation: Start an agency to generate cash flow, then use that capital and expertise to incubate or acquire digital products1.

  • Buy, Improve, Hold: Acquire small, profitable internet businesses, optimize operations, and hold for long-term value—a la Tiny’s model1.

  • Niche SaaS Tools: Build or acquire software that solves a specific pain point for a defined audience, then scale with minimal incremental cost1.

🧠 LIFE HACKS

  • Obsessive Learning: Andrew credits his rapid ascent to reading every business and investing book he could get his hands on. “Get obsessed, and you can go from zero to top percentile in a decade”1.

  • Pain as a Compass: Treat every failure as a tuition payment—each painful lesson is a shortcut for your next venture1.

💰 BEST IDEAS FOR FASTEST MONEY

  • Digital Themes & Templates: Pixel Union’s Shopify and Tumblr themes generated $10K/month in automatic revenue almost overnight—no inventory, no shipping, just pure margin1.

  • Acquisition Arbitrage: Buying profitable, under-optimized businesses and applying operational improvements can create outsized returns in a fraction of the time it takes to build from scratch1.

  • Pixel Union’s Growth: Started as a side project, quickly hit $10K/month, sold for $7M, bought back for $26M, and later went public at a $260M valuation1. Not bad for a business that began as a weekend favor!

  • Agency vs. Digital Product: Agencies are “medium” on the difficulty scale; digital products and SaaS can scale faster and with fewer headaches1.

  • The Buffett Effect: Andrew’s transformation from novice to top-tier operator happened in less than a decade, fueled by relentless study and adaptation1.

🔑 ACTIONABLE STRATEGIES

  • Step 1: Start Simple, Start Digital: Launch a product that doesn’t require inventory or physical logistics—think digital downloads, SaaS, or online services1.

  • Step 2: Validate Fast, Iterate Faster: Don’t overthink; launch, measure, and pivot. Andrew started businesses monthly, treating each as an experiment1.

  • Step 3: Postmortem Every Move: After each venture, dissect what worked and what didn’t. Document lessons and apply them ruthlessly to your next project1.

  • Step 4: Read & Apply: Devour business classics and Buffett’s letters. Apply frameworks like capital allocation and operational discipline to every venture1.

  • Step 5: Hold Your Winners: Resist the urge to cash out too soon—compound growth and operational improvements can turn a “good” business into a generational wealth engine1.

  • Warren Buffett’s Letters to Shareholders: The ultimate playbook for business and investing wisdom, referenced throughout the episode1.

  • Value Investing Classics: Andrew mentions reading “every single book” on value investing—think Graham, Dodd, and Munger1.

🚀 GROWTH HACKS & CHEAT CODES

  • Leverage Platform Ecosystems: Build on top of fast-growing platforms (like Shopify or Tumblr) to ride the wave of their growth1.

  • Operational Arbitrage: Buy businesses where you can apply proven operational improvements—think process automation, upsells, or better marketing1.

  • Network Effects: Relationships with founders (like Tumblr’s David Karp) can unlock unique business opportunities and early-mover advantages1.

📝 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

If you want to skip the potholes on your entrepreneurial journey, Andrew Wilkinson’s candid breakdown of his best and worst business ideas is your shortcut. From the sleepy cash flow of digital themes to the pain of selling too soon, Andrew’s story is a reminder that the right business model can change your life—and that the best education comes from both the bookshelf and the school of hard knocks. Whether you’re looking to build, buy, or just avoid rookie mistakes, this episode is a masterclass in turning lessons into leverage1.

🏷️ BUSINESSES MENTIONED & CONTEXT

  • Pixel Union: Launched as a side project selling Tumblr themes, later expanded to Shopify, became a cash machine, was sold, bought back, and taken public as WeCommerce1.

  • MetaLab: Andrew’s agency, which provided the cash flow and expertise to incubate other digital businesses1.

  • Tiny: The holding company that acquires and operates internet businesses, modeled after Berkshire Hathaway1.

🌐 COMMON THEME OF THE PODCAST

The recurring thread? Business is a game of iteration, learning, and capital allocation. Whether you’re launching, buying, or scaling, the winners are those who learn from every move, read voraciously, and never stop optimizing. In the world of Andrew Wilkinson, the best business isn’t just one you build—it’s one you understand, improve, and hold for the long run1.

🌎 External Factors

Economic & Consumer Behavior:
Andrew Wilkinson’s businesses, especially Pixel Union, thrived during a period when digital products (like website themes) were exploding in demand, thanks to the rapid adoption of platforms like Tumblr and Shopify. This digital gold rush made it easier to generate “automatic revenue” as consumers and small businesses flocked online, seeking easy-to-use, customizable web solutions1. The low overhead and global reach of digital products meant these businesses were less exposed to traditional economic downturns compared to brick-and-mortar or physical goods companies.

Regulatory & Competitive Conditions:
There’s no direct mention of regulatory hurdles in the episode, but the competitive landscape is clear: Andrew capitalized on being an early mover in emerging marketplaces (Tumblr, Shopify) before they became crowded. The acquisition of Tumblr by Yahoo! and subsequent decline of the platform is a classic example of how external corporate events can impact a business’s trajectory1. Shopify’s rise, meanwhile, provided a tailwind for Pixel Union’s pivot and growth.

📈 Business Metrics

  • Pixel Union’s Early Revenue: Quickly hit $10,000/month in recurring revenue, providing Wilkinson his first taste of “money while you sleep”1.

  • Sale and Repurchase: Sold Pixel Union for $7 million while it was generating $500K in net profit annually1.

  • Growth Post-Sale: When Wilkinson bought it back, the company was making $4 million in annual profit. He repurchased it for $26 million1.

  • Public Valuation: After acquiring additional companies and scaling operations, the business (as WeCommerce) went public at a $260 million valuation1.

  • Growth Rate: Pixel Union was growing at 50% per year at the time of the initial sale1.

  • Shift to Digital, Recurring Revenue: The move from agency work (service businesses) to digital products and SaaS reflected a broader industry trend toward scalable, low-overhead, high-margin businesses1.

  • Platform Dependency: Businesses built on top of platforms (Tumblr, Shopify) are subject to the fortunes of those platforms—Tumblr’s decline post-Yahoo acquisition forced a pivot, while Shopify’s growth proved to be a massive tailwind1.

  • Entrepreneurial Learning Curve: There’s a noticeable shift from “start everything” to a more disciplined, Buffett-inspired approach to capital allocation and business selection, mirroring a maturing entrepreneurial ecosystem1.

🚀 Business Initiatives

  • Incubation & Spin-Out: Pixel Union was incubated within MetaLab, then spun out as an independent entity to focus on growth1.

  • Acquisition & Roll-Up: After buying back Pixel Union, Wilkinson led a series of acquisitions, rolling up similar businesses under the WeCommerce umbrella before taking it public1.

  • Operational Improvements: Applying lessons from Warren Buffett, Wilkinson focused on optimizing capital allocation, operational efficiency, and margin improvement within his portfolio companies1.

  • Learning & Adaptation: Intensive self-education in value investing and business operations, leading to more sophisticated investment and operational strategies1.

🔮 Forward-Looking Statements

  • Compounding Growth: Wilkinson’s regret at selling too early and subsequent repurchase of Pixel Union underscores a forward-looking strategy: hold and compound great businesses rather than flipping them for short-term gains1.

  • Operational Leverage: Continued focus on buying, improving, and holding profitable internet businesses, applying operational best practices to unlock value1.

  • Education as a Moat: Emphasis on relentless learning and adaptation, with the goal of staying at the top percentile of business operators and investors within a decade1.

  • Platform Agnosticism: Recognition of the need to diversify across platforms to avoid being overly dependent on any single ecosystem (as happened with Tumblr)1.

In summary:
Andrew Wilkinson’s journey is a masterclass in riding economic and consumer trends, leveraging early-mover advantage, and evolving from a scattergun entrepreneur to a disciplined operator and investor. The numbers speak for themselves—$10K/month to $260M IPO—but the real story is in the lessons learned, the pivots made, and the relentless pursuit of operational excellence and compounding growth1.

Full episode we based our notes on: