The Upsell Mistake Every Business Owner Can Avoid

In partnership with

Go from AI overwhelmed to AI savvy professional

AI keeps coming up at work, but you still don't get it?

That's exactly why 1M+ professionals working at Google, Meta, and OpenAI read Superhuman AI daily.

Here's what you get:

  • Daily AI news that matters for your career - Filtered from 1000s of sources so you know what affects your industry.

  • Step-by-step tutorials you can use immediately - Real prompts and workflows that solve actual business problems.

  • New AI tools tested and reviewed - We try everything to deliver tools that drive real results.

  • All in just 3 minutes a day

The Million-Dollar Upsell Secret That Almost Killed a Deal

How one simple survey question turned a "no way" into a 1.9x profit boost

Look, I get it. You think you know what your customers want.

You've spent months building the "perfect" upsell. You're passionate about it. Your team loves it. It's gonna be the thing that takes your business to the next level.

But here's the thing that'll make your stomach drop...

You might be dead wrong.

The $500K Mistake Nobody Talks About

Picture this: You're sitting across from potential business partners. The deal's almost done. Everyone's excited. Then someone drops the upsell bomb.

"We've already got our backend figured out," they say, sliding over their masterpiece.

You look at it. Your heart sinks. It's got nothing to do with what customers actually bought. It's some random thing they fell in love with.

Sound familiar?

This exact scenario almost killed a deal worth millions. The partners were ready to walk away. Egos were bruised. Months of work down the drain.

But then came the game-changer question:

"Why don't we just ask the customers?"

The 30-Second Survey That Changes Everything

Here's what happened next (and why it'll blow your mind):

Instead of arguing about who was right, they did something crazy simple. They put both offers in front of real customers and asked one question:

"Which one do you want more?"

That's it. No fancy focus groups. No expensive market research. Just a straight-up, honest question.

The results?

85% chose the "more of what they just bought" option.

Not the shiny new thing. Not the "innovative" solution. They wanted more of what already worked for them.

Why This Works (And Why You're Probably Doing It Wrong)

Think about it like this:

When you go to McDonald's and order a Big Mac, what makes sense as an upsell?

A) Another burger or fries (more of what you wanted) B) A yoga mat (because "health is important")

Obviously A, right? But businesses make the yoga mat mistake all the time.

Your customers bought from you for a specific reason. They had a problem. You solved it. Now they're thinking: "This worked great! I wonder if they have more solutions like this?"

They're NOT thinking: "I hope they try to sell me something completely different!"

The Magic Formula That 1.9x'd Their Profits

Here's the simple framework that turned one deal into a profit-printing machine:

Step 1: Stop Guessing, Start Asking

  • Put your "brilliant" upsell idea aside

  • Create a simple survey with 2-3 options

  • Ask your customers what they actually want

  • Let the numbers decide (not your ego)

Step 2: Give Them "More of That"

  • Look at why customers bought originally

  • Create an advanced/premium version

  • Make it deeper, not different

  • Think "next level" not "totally new"

Step 3: Test Before You Invest

  • Survey first, build second

  • Keep it simple (2 options max)

  • Let customers vote with their wallets

  • Scale what wins, kill what doesn't

The Real Numbers (That'll Make Your Accountant Happy)

After implementing this approach:

  • 1.9x increase in customer lifetime value

  • 5x increase in profitable ad spend

  • Same profit margins, way more scale

Translation: They could spend 5 times more on ads and still make money. That's the difference between struggling to get customers and having to turn them away.

Your Next Move (Before Your Competition Figures This Out)

Stop building upsells in a vacuum. Your customers are literally waiting to tell you what they want to buy next.

Here's your homework:

  1. Survey your last 50 customers - Ask them what they wish you offered

  2. Test two options - Your idea vs. "more of what they bought"

  3. Build what wins - Not what you think should win

  4. Scale what works - Then repeat the process

Remember: The goal isn't to be right. It's to make money.

And sometimes, making money means admitting your customers know better than you do.

The bottom line? Stop falling in love with your ideas. Start falling in love with what actually sells.

Your bank account will thank you.

P.S. - That deal that almost fell apart? It ended up being one of the most profitable partnerships ever. All because someone was brave enough to ask a simple question: "What do you actually want to buy?"